CAIN Ends, But the Fight Against Nazism Continues





CAIN Ends, But the Fight Against Nazism Continues
By Writinglegend







(Europeia – November 27, 2017) – Europeia has withdrawn from the Coalition Against the Ideology of Nazism (CAIN) after an internal vote to end the organization.

"The signatories of the Coalition Against the Ideology of Nazism have voted to end it," President Rach stated in front of the Senate. "As such, I would like to request that the Senate repeal this treaty."

The Senate unanimously confirmed the repeal after President Rach requested an expedited vote.

CAIN has been a hot-button electoral topic for the past six months since its creator went inactive and the organization fell into disarray. The coalition never seemingly recovered from its lapse of leadership and trudged on with its lofty internal structure. Despite past promises to revive the organization through separate and unique means, all failed and the organization fell deeper into an abyss of inactivity.

The final nail in the coffin for CAIN was not its activity, nor its structure, but the despicable actions by the creator of the organization that, undoubtedly, tarnished the name of CAIN. The creator and their actions will forever be linked to the organization. All signatories agreed that it was best to not uphold their name through its continued life, and to ensure the speedy death of the coalition.

"CAIN has [...] its legacy marred by Brunhilde," Le Libertie stated on the Senate floor while explaining his support for the repeal. This sentiment was shared by Senate Speaker Drecq.

Minister of Foreign Affairs Isaris expressed a similar sentiment when our EBC reporter inquired on the state of the coalition. "The repeal of the CAIN treaty was an unfortunate necessity in the aftermath of the revelations about the player behind Brunhilde," he stated. "CAIN's former members remain committed to standing against Nazism outside of the now defunct organization."

When questioned on what this new commitment would take the form of, Minister of Foreign Affairs Isaris described a future possible venture being an "informal agreement" where CAIN signatories and other regions can proclaim the publicly shared stance to fight Nazism in NationStates.

Both the President of Europeia and the Minister of Foreign Affairs reaffirmed Europeia's fight against Nazism, and the continued prolific role the Europeian Republican Navy (ERN) will play in that fight.

"The ERN will continue to target Nazi and Nazi-affiliated regions in its operations moving forward."

While CAIN may have ended, the fight against Nazism in NationStates has not. Europeia continues to stay strong with her values against hate speech and in-game Nazism, and will use all means to oppose these disgusting players. With an informal agreement being considered, and continued military operations, it seems that Europeia, her allies, and her friends are more primed than ever to lead and continue the fight against Nazism.
 
If I'm not mistaken, the swastika is already banned on site, it really isn't a huge leap forward to ban Nazism at this point, they are already banning their imagery. :p
 
Vac said:
If I'm not mistaken, the swastika is already banned on site, it really isn't a huge leap forward to ban Nazism at this point, they are already banning their imagery. :p
True, but it does get harder to define what counts as 'Nazism' when there are a lot of far-right ideologies that are related to Nazis but aren't Nazis.

I mean, Germany has baned Nazis, but unless I missed something, fascistic, racist, antisemitic parties still do exist in Germany, albeit very very small usually (though a Neo-Naziesque party did do well in recent elections, capitalizing on the Refugee crisis and the same kind of thing that led to Le Penn, Brexit and Trump.)

So on the one hand, the mods can ban their symbolism, but then they just use others (IRL neo-nazis in germany and other swastikaless nations have adopted the Iron Cross, for example) but then from there, it gets harder. We could likely all or most of us agree to have them ban antisemitism and other core Nazi ideas (advocating Genocide is already banned) but at the same time, one person's antisemitism is another person's not - see Linda Sarsour (who I would say is at least moderately antisemitic and who pals around with much more Antisemitic people, like Louis Farakhan, but a lot of far-left or anti-Israel Jewish people seem to love - she was actually a speaker at a panel on Antisemitism recently). And not even jewish people as a whole agree on what is and isn't truly antisemitic.

So we'd be back with the mods having to make bans based on some very subtle and subjective distinctions in complex political ideologies. Or we'd have mods making far too broad a ban list, or different mods enforcing the same rules differently - it already happens, we'd just exacerbate that.

Basically, banning Nazis from the site is easier said than done, though there are more things that could be done (getting rid of some of the more obvious markers, including the name Nazi, National Socialism, obviously recycled Third Reich propaganda *looks at Kaisarreich*)
 
Vac said:
If I'm not mistaken, the swastika is already banned on site, it really isn't a huge leap forward to ban Nazism at this point, they are already banning their imagery. :p
I've always been told, but I'm not sure if it's true that the only reason they banned the swastika was because of bad external press.
 
Rach said:
Vac said:
If I'm not mistaken, the swastika is already banned on site, it really isn't a huge leap forward to ban Nazism at this point, they are already banning their imagery. :p
I've always been told, but I'm not sure if it's true that the only reason they banned the swastika was because of bad external press.
Then why don't we try to make bad external press even more, if we really wanna drive Nazis out of the game?
 
Kylia Quilor said:
Rach said:
Vac said:
If I'm not mistaken, the swastika is already banned on site, it really isn't a huge leap forward to ban Nazism at this point, they are already banning their imagery. :p
I've always been told, but I'm not sure if it's true that the only reason they banned the swastika was because of bad external press.
Then why don't we try to make bad external press even more, if we really wanna drive Nazis out of the game?
That sounds like an excellent way to go about it, really.

And I do agree with your assessment on the difficulty of banning Nazis from the game, it is significantly easier said than done, for sure.
 
Rach said:
Perhaps an op ed in a newspaper about the growth of Nazism online that mentions NS?
That would possibly help, but NS is still such a tiny portion of online Nazis.
 
Common-Sense Politics said:
If anybody wants tips on how to get op eds published, hit me up.
can you generate me some positive press
 
Back
Top